Rent vs Buy Calculator
Should you rent or buy? Compare the full cost of renting vs buying a home, including mortgage interest, taxes, equity, appreciation, transaction costs and what your down payment could earn invested, and see when buying breaks even.
Advanced assumptions
Of the price, paid when you buy.
Agent fees and transfer costs, of the sale price.
Repairs and upkeep, of the home's value.
Yearly rise in insurance, HOA and other fixed costs.
Parking, pet rent, fees.
Result After 10 Years
Renting comes out about $9,507.43 ahead.
Buying does not catch up within your 10-year stay. If you stayed longer, it would become comparable after about 11 years 10 months.
- Net Worth if Buying
- $234,028.95
- Net Worth if Renting
- $243,536.39
- Home Equity
- $266,282.95
- Renter Portfolio
- $243,536.39
- Wealth Difference
- −$9,507.43 rent
- Break-Even
- 11 years 10 months
- Month 1: Owning
- $2,872.62
- Month 1: Renting
- $2,220.00
Net worth if buying is the home's estimated value minus the mortgage balance and selling costs, plus anything invested in months when owning cost less than renting. Net worth if renting is the down payment and closing costs invested, plus the monthly difference whenever renting costs less. This result depends on your assumptions; it is not a prediction.
Estimates only, based entirely on the assumptions you enter. Home prices, rents and investment returns are uncertain and can be lower or higher than assumed, so neither option is right for everyone. The model uses a fixed-rate mortgage and leaves out PMI, income-tax effects (mortgage-interest deduction, capital-gains rules, tax on investment gains), moving costs, security deposits and major one-off repairs unless you include them in the inputs.
Cost of Renting vs Buying Over 10 Years
Renting
- Monthly rent (year 1)
- $2,200.00
- Total rent paid
- $302,646.41
- Total renter's insurance
- $2,751.33
- Other rental costs
- $0.00
- Total rental costs
- $305,397.74
- Investment gains (opportunity cost of buying)
- −$95,971.43
- Net cost of renting
- $209,426.32
Buying
- Monthly mortgage payment (P&I)
- $2,022.62
- Mortgage interest paid
- $193,997.73
- Property taxes
- $51,130.93
- Home insurance
- $20,634.98
- HOA fees
- $0.00
- Maintenance
- $46,482.67
- Closing costs
- $12,000.00
- Selling costs
- $32,253.99
- Home appreciation
- −$137,566.55
- Net cost of buying
- $218,933.75
Down payment + closing (upfront cash)
$92,000.00
Mortgage principal paid
$48,716.40
Home value / balance owed
$537,566.55 / $271,283.60
The down payment and principal are not counted as costs: they stay yours as home equity and come back when you sell. Interest, taxes, insurance, HOA, maintenance and transaction costs are not recovered. Net cost of buying − net cost of renting = +$9,507.43, which is exactly the wealth difference in favour of renting.
Renting vs Buying Over Time
Estimated net worth if you sold in each year (higher is better). Where the green line crosses above the blue one, buying has caught up. Buying does not catch up within your 10-year stay. If you stayed longer, it would become comparable after about 11 years 10 months.
| Year | Net Cost Renting | Net Cost Buying | Home Equity | Net Worth Renting | Net Worth Buying | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $20,905.02 | $55,729.57 | $95,576.72 | $105,681.27 | $70,856.72 | −$34,824.55 rent |
| 5 | $104,497.60 | $131,788.25 | $164,154.50 | $163,622.58 | $136,331.92 | −$27,290.65 rent |
| 10 (your stay) | $209,426.32 | $218,933.75 | $266,282.95 | $243,536.39 | $234,028.95 | −$9,507.43 rent |
What If? Scenario Analysis
Conservative
Appreciation −1.5 pts, rent growth −1 pt, maintenance +0.5 pt
−$115,129.49 renting
Break-even: none within 40 yrs
Base case
Your assumptions
−$9,507.43 renting
Break-even: 11 years 10 months
Optimistic
Appreciation +1.5 pts, rent growth +1 pt
+$76,926.42 buying
Break-even: 4 years 5 months
Conservative and optimistic describe the outlook for buying. Each scenario changes only the listed assumptions; the wealth difference is measured after your 10-year stay.
How This Result Was Calculated
- Home value after 10 years: $400,000.00 × (1 + 3%)^10 = $537,566.55.
- Equity if you sell: $537,566.55 − $271,283.60 mortgage balance − $32,253.99 selling costs = $234,028.95.
- Renting: the $92,000.00 upfront cash stays invested at 6% a year, and each month the cheaper option invests the difference; the renter's portfolio reaches $243,536.39.
- Difference: $234,028.95 − $243,536.39 = −$9,507.43 (renting ahead).
Should you rent or buy? This rent vs buy calculator compares the full financial picture of renting versus buying a home over the years you expect to stay. It goes beyond comparing rent with a mortgage payment: it counts mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, HOA fees, maintenance, closing and selling costs, home appreciation, the equity you build, and what your down payment could earn if you invested it and kept renting.
Enter your rent, the home price, your mortgage terms, your expected investment return and how long you plan to stay. The calculator shows whether renting or buying leaves you wealthier under your assumptions, by how much, and when buying breaks even, along with conservative and optimistic scenarios. The answer depends entirely on those assumptions, so treat it as a guide rather than a prediction.
How the Rent vs Buy Calculator Works
The calculator follows two versions of you over the same years. In one you buy the home; in the other you rent and invest the cash you would otherwise have spent on the down payment and closing costs. Each month both households spend the same amount: whichever option costs less that month invests the difference at your investment return. When you sell, it compares what each household owns. The buyer owns the home's value minus the mortgage balance and selling costs (plus any investments); the renter owns an investment portfolio. The option with more wealth at the end is the better financial choice under your assumptions.
This avoids the two most common mistakes in rent vs buy comparisons: treating the whole mortgage payment as a cost (the principal part builds equity you get back) and ignoring what the down payment could have earned if you had kept renting.
What Does the Rent vs Buy Calculator Consider?
- Mortgage payments and interest: a fixed-rate loan amortized month by month. Interest is a cost; principal reduces the balance and becomes equity. See the split year by year with the amortization calculator.
- Property taxes, insurance and HOA: taxes as a percentage of the home's current value; insurance and HOA fees rise each year with the cost-inflation rate.
- Maintenance: a yearly percentage of the home's value for repairs and upkeep, often budgeted at around 1%.
- Rent increases: rent rises once a year by the rate you choose; renter's insurance and other rental costs rise with cost inflation.
- Home appreciation: the home's value compounds at your assumed rate, which may be zero or negative. It only turns into money when you sell.
- Closing and selling costs: a percentage of the price when you buy and of the sale price when you sell. These are never recovered.
- Opportunity cost and investment returns: the down payment and closing costs stay invested if you rent, and either household invests its monthly savings. The investment calculator shows how that compounding works on its own.
Rent vs Buy Formula
Net worth if buying = home value − mortgage balance − selling costs + invested savings
Net worth if renting = (down payment + closing costs) invested + invested monthly savings
Difference = net worth if buying − net worth if renting
The same comparison can be written as costs. The net cost of buying is interest + property taxes + insurance + HOA + maintenance + closing costs + selling costs − appreciation. The net cost of renting is rent + renter's insurance + other rental costs − the investment gains the renter earns. The difference between the two net costs equals the difference in net worth, so the two views always agree and nothing is counted twice. The monthly mortgage payment uses the standard formula, M = P × r(1 + r)^n ÷ ((1 + r)^n − 1), where P is the loan amount, r the monthly rate and n the number of payments; the mortgage calculator and loan calculator use the same formula.
What Is the Break-Even Point Between Renting and Buying?
The break-even point is how long you need to stay before buying leaves you at least as wealthy as renting, counting the cost of selling. Early on, buying is behind by roughly the closing and selling costs; it catches up as the loan is repaid, the home appreciates and rent rises. The calculator reports the first month from which buying stays ahead. If that never happens within 40 years under your assumptions, it says so rather than forcing a result. Changing one assumption at a time on the example below shows how much it moves:
| Change | Break-Even | Ahead After 10 Years |
|---|---|---|
| Example as entered | 11 years 10 months | $9,507.43 renting |
| Mortgage rate 5% instead of 6.5% | 5 years 1 month | $51,001.60 buying |
| Appreciation 4% instead of 3% | 6 years | $35,620.61 buying |
| Rent $2,600 instead of $2,200 | 4 years 10 months | $63,947.39 buying |
| Investment return 8% instead of 6% | Not within 40 years | $53,163.89 renting |
| Investment return 4% instead of 6% | 7 years 1 month | $27,756.26 buying |
Higher appreciation, faster rent increases, a lower mortgage rate and a longer stay pull the break-even earlier. Higher closing, selling and maintenance costs and a higher investment return push it later, because they make owning more expensive or renting-and-investing more rewarding. A larger down payment reduces interest but also ties up more cash that could have been invested, so its effect depends on how the mortgage rate compares with your investment return.
How to Interpret Your Rent vs Buy Results
- Renting is cheaper: with your assumptions, investing the down payment and paying rent leaves you wealthier when you would have sold. Renting is not "throwing money away": you pay for housing either way, and owners also pay unrecoverable costs such as interest, taxes and maintenance.
- Buying is cheaper: equity growth and appreciation outweigh the extra costs and the lost investment returns over your stay. Check that the result holds in the conservative scenario before relying on it.
- The results are close: a difference within about 1% of the home price is well inside the uncertainty of any forecast. Non-financial factors such as stability, flexibility, schools and control over your home should carry more weight.
When Renting May Make More Sense
Renting often comes out ahead when you expect to move within a few years, because closing and selling costs together can reach 8–10% of the price and need time to be recovered. It can also win when mortgage rates are high relative to rents, when local prices are high compared with rents, when your job or location may change, or when a small down payment would leave you with little emergency cash. Renting keeps your savings liquid and lets you invest them elsewhere; the savings calculator can help you plan a future down payment.
When Buying May Make More Sense
Buying tends to look better the longer you stay, especially with a stable income, a favorable mortgage rate, prices that are reasonable compared with local rents, and rents that are rising quickly. Each payment repays some principal, and once the mortgage is paid off your housing cost drops to taxes, insurance and upkeep while rent would keep rising. Make sure the payment fits comfortably: the house affordability calculator estimates a price range, and the refinance calculator helps if rates fall after you buy.
Rent vs Buy Example Calculation
Illustrative assumptions: a $400,000.00 home with $80,000.00 (20%) down, a 6.5% 30-year mortgage, 1.1% property tax, $1,800.00 a year insurance, 1% maintenance, 3% appreciation, 3% closing and 6% selling costs, against $2,200.00 rent rising 3% a year, $20.00 a month renter's insurance and a 6% investment return. Calculated with the same engine as the calculator above.
| Sell After | Home Equity | Net Worth Buying | Net Worth Renting | Ahead |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 years | $128,555.63 | $102,330.18 | $134,001.07 | $31,670.89 renting |
| 5 years | $164,154.50 | $136,331.92 | $163,622.58 | $27,290.65 renting |
| 10 years | $266,282.95 | $234,028.95 | $243,536.39 | $9,507.43 renting |
| 15 years | $390,997.71 | $354,041.65 | $332,443.12 | $21,598.54 buying |
| 20 years | $544,315.59 | $516,863.01 | $444,883.88 | $71,979.13 buying |
The mortgage payment is $2,022.62 a month, and with taxes, insurance and maintenance owning costs about $2,872.62 in the first month, against $2,220.00 for renting. The renter starts with the $92,000.00 down payment and closing costs invested and adds the monthly difference. After 5 years the home is worth $463,709.63, but after the mortgage balance and selling costs, buying is still $27,290.65 behind. After 10 years the gap has narrowed to $9,507.43 renting: buying has paid $193,997.73 of interest and $51,130.93 of property tax, while renting has paid $302,646.41 of rent and earned $95,971.43 on its investments. Buying catches up after about 11 years 10 months and pulls ahead after that. With a slightly different set of assumptions the answer flips, which is why it is worth testing the scenarios rather than relying on a single result.
Assumptions and Limitations
All results are estimates. The model assumes a fixed-rate mortgage, steady appreciation, rent growth and investment returns, and that both households invest every dollar of monthly savings. It does not include PMI, income-tax effects such as the mortgage-interest deduction or capital-gains rules, moving costs or one-off repairs. Investment returns are not guaranteed and can be negative, and over long periods inflation affects both options; the inflation calculator converts future amounts into today's dollars. For long-term planning beyond housing, try the retirement calculator.
How to Use the Rent vs Buy Calculator
- Under Home Purchase, enter the home price, your down payment (as a percentage or a dollar amount), the mortgage rate and term, the property tax rate, homeowners insurance, any HOA fees and the appreciation you expect.
- Under Renting, enter the monthly rent for a comparable home and how much you expect it to rise each year.
- Enter the return you could earn by investing money you do not spend on the home, and how many years you expect to stay before selling.
- Open Advanced assumptions to adjust closing costs, selling costs, maintenance, cost inflation, renter's insurance and other rental costs.
- Read the result: which option leaves you wealthier after your stay, by how much, and the break-even point when buying catches up.
- Compare the cost breakdown, the chart and year-by-year table, and the conservative and optimistic scenarios to see how sensitive the answer is.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it cheaper to rent or buy?
It depends on how long you stay, the price-to-rent ratio where you live, the mortgage rate, how fast rents and home values rise, and what you could earn by investing instead. Buying has large upfront and selling costs, so renting usually wins for short stays and buying tends to catch up over longer ones. The calculator shows which comes out ahead with your own numbers.
How many years should I stay in a home before buying makes sense?
There is no universal number. Under the example assumptions on this page ($400,000 home, 20% down, 6.5% mortgage, $2,200 rent, 3% appreciation and rent growth, 6% investment return), buying breaks even after about 12 years; a lower mortgage rate or higher rent brings that down to around 5 years, while a higher investment return can push it beyond 40. Enter your own figures to see your break-even point.
What is the break-even point between renting and buying?
It is the time it takes for buying to leave you at least as wealthy as renting, after counting the cost of selling the home and the investment returns a renter would have earned on the down payment. The calculator reports the first month from which buying stays ahead, or says clearly if that does not happen within 40 years.
Does a larger down payment make buying better?
Not automatically. A larger down payment lowers the loan, the monthly payment and total interest, but it also ties up cash that could have been invested if you rented. If your expected investment return is higher than your mortgage rate, a bigger down payment can make buying look worse; if it is lower, it can help. It can also help you avoid PMI, which this calculator does not model.
Should I include property taxes when comparing rent vs buy?
Yes. Property taxes are an ongoing, unrecoverable cost of owning, often 1% or more of the home's value each year, and they usually rise as the home appreciates. Leaving them out makes buying look cheaper than it is. Renters pay them only indirectly, through rent.
How does home appreciation affect the calculation?
Appreciation increases the home's value and therefore the equity you keep when you sell, which is one of the main reasons buying can win over long stays. It is not guaranteed: prices can stall or fall, and gains are only realized when you sell, after selling costs. Test a low or zero appreciation rate to see how much your result relies on it.
How does investment return affect the rent vs buy decision?
The investment return is what the renter earns on the down payment, closing costs and any monthly savings. A higher return makes renting more attractive and pushes the break-even point later; a lower return favors buying. Use a realistic long-term, after-tax and after-fee rate, not a best-case figure.
What happens if rent increases every year?
Rising rent makes renting more expensive over time, while a fixed-rate mortgage payment stays the same. Faster rent growth therefore favors buying and brings the break-even point earlier. The calculator increases rent once a year by the rate you enter.
Is buying always better than renting long term?
No. Buying often comes out ahead over long periods, but not always: high prices relative to rent, high mortgage rates, heavy maintenance, low appreciation or strong investment returns can keep renting ahead even after decades. The calculator shows when, or whether, buying catches up under your assumptions.
Are closing and selling costs included?
Yes. Closing costs are a percentage of the purchase price paid when you buy, and selling costs (such as agent commissions and transfer fees) are a percentage of the sale price paid when you sell. Both are unrecoverable and are a major reason renting tends to win for short stays. You can change both under Advanced assumptions.
Related Calculators
Mortgage Calculator
Estimate home mortgage payments including principal, interest, taxes, and insurance.
House Affordability Calculator
How much house can I afford? Estimate a recommended and maximum home price from income, debts, down payment and rate, with the full monthly cost.
Amortization Calculator
Generate a full loan amortization schedule and see how extra payments save interest.
Refinance Calculator
Compare your current mortgage with a new loan: payments, closing costs, break-even and total cost.
Investment Calculator
Calculate investment returns, compound annual growth rate (CAGR), and portfolio value.
Inflation Calculator
Project future costs and purchasing power, or compare prices with historical CPI.
Loan Calculator
Calculate monthly loan payments, interest charges, and loan payoff terms.
Tip Calculator
Split restaurant bills and compute tip percentages per person easily.
More Finance Calculators
Last updated: October 25, 2026.