Lease vs Buy Car Calculator

Compare the total cost of leasing a car with buying it (cash or financed) over the same period, including fees, mileage charges, running costs, the loan balance you would still owe and the car's resale value.

Vehicle and Comparison

Negotiated purchase price before tax.

Applied to the purchase. Enter the lease payment including its tax.

Value lost each year, compounding. Resale after 3 yr ≈ $21,494. New cars often lose 15–20% a year early on.

Lease Details

As quoted, including any monthly tax.

Leases repeat back to back if the period is longer.

Down payment / cap cost reduction, excluding the first payment.

Leasing company fee to set up the lease.

Charged when you return the car at lease end.

Documentation or other non-refundable fees.

Miles included in the lease.

Per mile over the allowance, charged at lease end.

Refundable, so it is not a cost (only a forgone return if opportunity cost is on).

Buy Details

Sales tax is financed with the price.

Annual percentage rate on the loan.

Monthly payment ≈ $672.25

Origination or other loan fees, paid upfront.

Running Costs per Year

Enter the same figure on both sides when a cost does not differ. A leased car is often under warranty, so maintenance can be lower.

Leases often require higher coverage.

Opportunity Cost (Optional)

Estimated Result Over 3 Years

Leasing costs less

Estimated savings: $1,931.44 over 36 months.

Total Cost of Leasing
$27,990.00
Net Cost of Buying
$29,921.44
Monthly Lease Payment
$450.00
Monthly Loan Payment
$672.25
Est. Resale Value
$21,494.37
Loan Balance at End
$15,014.79
Interest Paid in Period
$5,265.81
Lease Fees + Mileage
$1,290.00
Running Costs (Lease / Buy)
$7,500 / $8,700
Sales Tax on Purchase
$2,450.00

Estimate only, not a guaranteed cost or financial advice.

This calculator provides estimates based on the information you enter. Actual lease and loan contracts, taxes, insurance, maintenance costs and resale values vary, so results are not guaranteed costs or financial advice.

Lease vs. Buy Cost Comparison

Lease$27,990.00

Buy (financed)$29,921.44

Cumulative Net Cost by Year

Year 3: Lease $27,990, Buy (financed) $29,921.

Each point is the net cost if the comparison ended that year: for buying, cash paid minus the car's estimated value plus any loan balance still owed; for leasing, everything paid so far. Buying usually starts higher and flattens once the loan is repaid, while leasing climbs steadily.

How Was This Calculated?

Total cost of leasing (1 lease)
Due at signing + acquisition + other fees$3,895.00
Lease payments ($450.00 × 36)$16,200.00
Disposition fee(s)$395.00
Excess mileage (0 mi × $0.25)$0.00
Insurance, maintenance, registration (3 yr)$7,500.00
= Total cost of leasing$27,990.00
Net cost of buying (financed)
Down payment$3,500.00
Loan payments (36 × $672.25)$24,201.02
Loan fees$0.00
Insurance, maintenance, registration (3 yr)$8,700.00
= Cash paid during the period$36,401.02
− Estimated resale value after 3 yr$21,494.37
+ Loan balance still owed$15,014.79
= Net cost of buying$29,921.44

Check: net cost of buying = depreciation $13,505.63 + sales tax $2,450.00 + interest $5,265.81 + loan fees $0.00 + running costs $8,700.00 = $29,921.44. The loan principal is counted once: through the down payment and payments made, plus the balance you would still have to repay when selling.

Lease vs. Finance vs. Cash

Leasing compared with financing and paying cash over 3 years
LeaseFinanceCash
Paid at the start$4,345.00$3,500.00$37,450.00
Monthly payment$450.00$672.25—
Interest paid in period—$5,265.81$0.00
Owned at the endNothing (car returned)$21,494 car − $15,015 loan$21,494 car
Net cost over 3 yr$27,990.00$29,921.44$24,655.62

Paying cash avoids interest but ties up more money upfront; turn on opportunity cost to account for what that money could have earned. For more loan detail use the auto loan calculator; to work out a lease payment from the price, residual and money factor use the car lease calculator.

Assumptions

  • Both options are compared over the same 36 months. If the period is longer than the lease term, you lease again on identical terms; if it ends mid-lease, only payments made so far count.
  • The purchased car is sold at the end of the period for its estimated value, and any remaining loan balance is repaid from the sale. Selling costs are not included.
  • Sales tax is charged on the purchase price and financed with the loan (or paid upfront for cash). Enter lease payments including their tax; some states tax leases differently.
  • Running costs are flat each year, without inflation. Excess wear-and-tear charges and early termination fees are not included.

Should I lease or buy a car? The honest answer is that it depends on how long you keep the car, how far you drive and the deals you are offered, which is why this lease vs buy car calculator compares the full cost of both over the same period instead of just the monthly payments. A lease payment is usually lower, but at the end you hand the car back; a loan payment is higher, but you are left with a car that still has resale value.

Enter a lease quote and a purchase price, choose to finance with an auto loan or pay cash, and pick a comparison period from one to ten years. The calculator adds up the car lease vs purchase cost on each side, including fees, excess mileage, insurance, maintenance, the loan balance you would still owe and the car's estimated resale value, then shows whether leasing vs buying a car is cheaper for your numbers, by how much, and how the gap changes year by year. If you are asking whether it is cheaper to lease or buy a car, this gives you an estimate based on your own figures rather than a rule of thumb.

How Does the Lease vs. Buy Calculator Work?

The calculator lines up every cost of each option over the same comparison period. On the lease side it adds the amount due at signing, acquisition and other fees, every monthly payment, the disposition fee when a lease ends and any excess-mileage charge, plus the insurance, maintenance and registration you enter. If the period is longer than the lease term, it assumes you sign a new lease on the same terms.

On the buy side it adds the down payment (or the full price plus tax for a cash purchase), the loan payments made during the period, loan fees and running costs. At the end it assumes you sell the car for its estimated value and pay off whatever is left on the loan. The difference between the two totals is the estimated saving, and results within about 2% (at least $250) are shown as a near tie, because the inputs themselves are estimates.

Leasing vs. Buying: Key Differences

Key differences between leasing and buying a car
LeasingBuying
Ownership and equityYou never own the car; it goes back at lease end unless you buy it out.You own the car and build equity as the loan is repaid.
Monthly paymentUsually lower: you pay for depreciation during the term plus a rent charge.Usually higher: you repay the whole price plus interest.
Upfront costAmount due at signing, first payment and fees.Down payment, sales tax (often financed) and fees, or the full price in cash.
MileageAnnual allowance; extra miles are charged per mile at lease end.No limit, though high mileage lowers resale value.
MaintenanceOften covered by the warranty for most of the term; excess wear is charged at return.Your responsibility, and repairs tend to grow after the warranty ends.
End of termReturn the car (disposition fee), buy it out, or lease again.Keep driving with no payment, sell, or trade in.
DepreciationBuilt into the payment; the residual value is set at signing.You carry the risk and benefit of the actual resale value.

Formula and Calculation Method

Total Lease Cost

Total Lease Cost = Due at Signing + Lease Fees + Monthly Payments + Disposition Fee + Excess Mileage + Running Costs

Excess Mileage Cost = max(0, Miles Driven − Miles Allowed) × Charge per Mile

Financed Purchase

Loan Payment = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n)

P is the amount financed (price + sales tax − down payment), r the APR ÷ 12 and n the loan term in months.

Outstanding Loan Balance

Balance after k payments = P(1 + r)^k − Payment × ((1 + r)^k − 1) ÷ r

Net Cost of Buying

Net Buying Cost = Cash Paid in Period − Resale Value + Remaining Loan Balance

= Depreciation + Sales Tax + Interest Paid + Loan Fees + Running Costs

The two lines are the same number: the loan principal is counted once, partly through the payments you make and partly through the balance repaid when the car is sold. Resale value is estimated from compounding annual depreciation (Value = Price × (1 − d)^years) unless you enter it directly. With opportunity cost turned on, each payment is grown at your assumed return to the end of the period, which charges each option for the investment income its earlier payments give up. Real lease contracts, tax rules, insurance premiums and resale values vary, so treat the result as an estimate.

Practical Examples

Example 1: Leasing vs. financing a new car over three years

A $35,000 car, 7% sales tax, 12,000 miles a year and 15% depreciation a year. Lease: $450/month for 36 months, $3,000 due at signing, $895 acquisition fee, $395 disposition fee and a 12,000-mile allowance. Loan: $3,500 down at 7% APR for 60 months. Running costs are left out (treated as equal) to keep the steps clear.

  1. Lease: $3,895.00 upfront + $450 × 36 = $16,200.00 + $395.00 disposition = $20,490.00.
  2. Loan: $35,000 + $2,450.00 tax − $3,500 down = $33,950.00 financed, so the payment is $672.25.
  3. After 36 payments ($24,201.02), $15,014.79 is still owed, and the car is worth about $35,000 × 0.85³ = $21,494.37.
  4. Net buying cost = $3,500.00 + $24,201.02 − $21,494.37 + $15,014.79 = $21,221.44.
  5. Leasing is about $731 cheaper over three years: close enough that a slightly better resale value, loan rate or lease deal could flip the result.

Example 2: Leasing vs. buying over five years

The same car kept for five years and driven 15,000 miles a year. Lease: two back-to-back 30-month leases at $470/month with the same fees and allowance. Buy: the same 60-month loan, or paying $37,450.00 cash.

Five-year comparison of leasing, financing and paying cash
Lease (2 leases)FinanceCash
Paid during 5 years$40,530.00$43,835.04$37,450.00
of which excess mileage$3,750.00——
Interest—$6,385.04$0.00
− Resale value—$15,529.69$15,529.69
Net cost$40,530.00$28,305.36$21,920.31

The loan is fully repaid in month 60, so nothing is owed at the end. Over five years financing costs about $12,225 less than leasing, and paying cash saves another $6,385 in interest (before counting what that cash could have earned elsewhere). Driving 3,000 miles a year over the allowance adds $3,750.00 to the lease side.

When Should You Lease a Car?

  • You like driving a new car with the latest safety features and want to change cars every two to four years.
  • You drive predictably and stay within the mileage allowance.
  • You want a lower monthly payment and prefer most repairs to fall under the factory warranty.
  • You use the car for business; lease payments may be partly deductible, depending on your tax situation.

When Should You Buy a Car?

  • You plan to keep the car well beyond the loan term; years with no payment are where buying usually pulls ahead.
  • You drive a lot of miles, or unpredictably, and want to avoid excess-mileage charges.
  • You want to own an asset, customize the car or avoid wear-and-tear inspections.
  • You can get a low loan rate or pay cash without draining your emergency savings.

These are general considerations, not rules. The cheaper option depends on your actual quotes, how long you keep cars and how they hold their value.

Related Calculators

Work out a lease payment from the price, residual value and money factor with the car lease calculator, or see a full loan schedule, trade-in and tax detail in the auto loan calculator. The loan calculator handles any fixed-rate loan, the sales tax calculator estimates tax on the purchase, and the APR calculator shows how fees change the true cost of financing. To budget fuel for your annual mileage, try the fuel cost calculator.

This calculator provides estimates based on the information you enter. Actual lease and loan contracts, taxes, insurance, maintenance costs and resale values vary, so results are not guaranteed costs or financial advice.

How to Use the Lease vs Buy Car Calculator

  1. Enter the vehicle price, your sales tax rate, the comparison period and how many miles you expect to drive each year.
  2. Enter the expected depreciation per year, or switch to the resale value you expect at the end of the period.
  3. Fill in the lease quote: monthly payment, term, amount due at signing, acquisition and disposition fees, mileage allowance and excess-mileage charge.
  4. Choose to finance or pay cash. For a loan, enter the down payment, APR, term and any loan fees; the monthly payment is calculated for you.
  5. Add yearly insurance, maintenance and registration for each option, and optionally turn on opportunity cost with an assumed investment return.
  6. Read which option costs less, the estimated savings, the cost breakdown and chart, and the step-by-step calculation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to lease or buy a car?

It depends on the period. Over two or three years leasing can cost about the same as or less than buying, because a new car loses value fastest early on and a loan has front-loaded interest. Over five years or more, buying and keeping the car is usually cheaper, since you stop making payments while still owning something of value. Enter your own quotes to compare.

What is the difference between leasing and financing a car?

Financing is borrowing to buy the car: you repay the full price plus interest and own the car. Leasing is paying to use the car for a set term: payments cover the expected depreciation plus a rent charge, and you return the car or buy it out at the end.

Does leasing a car build equity?

Generally no. Lease payments do not build ownership. You only gain equity if you buy the car at lease end for less than it is worth, which can happen when used-car prices are high.

What happens at the end of a car lease?

You usually return the car and pay a disposition fee plus any excess-mileage or excess wear-and-tear charges, buy it for the purchase-option price in the contract, or trade it in for a new lease. Check your contract for the exact fees.

Is buying a car cheaper over five years?

Often, but not always. Over five years a typical loan is paid off or nearly paid off and the car still has resale value, while leasing over the same period means a second lease with new upfront costs. High mileage widens the gap; a very low lease rate or steep depreciation can narrow it.

What credit score is needed to lease a car?

There is no single cutoff. Many leasing companies reserve their best money factors for prime credit, often scores around 700 or higher, while lower scores may still qualify with a higher rate or larger amount due at signing. Requirements vary by lender.

Can I negotiate a car lease payment?

Yes. You can negotiate the vehicle selling price (cap cost), ask for the base money factor without a dealer markup, and question add-on fees. The residual value is set by the leasing company and is generally not negotiable.

Are lease payments tax-deductible?

For personal use, generally not. If the car is used for business, part of the lease payments may be deductible in proportion to business use, subject to limits. Rules depend on your country, state and circumstances, so check with a tax professional.

How does annual mileage affect leasing costs?

Lower allowances mean higher residual values and lower payments, but every mile over the allowance is charged at lease end, often $0.15 to $0.30 a mile. Driving 15,000 miles a year on a 12,000-mile lease adds 9,000 excess miles over three years, about $2,250 at $0.25 a mile.

Should I include insurance and maintenance in the comparison?

Yes, when they differ. Leases often require higher insurance coverage, while a leased car is usually under warranty so repairs cost less. If the costs are the same either way, they cancel out and do not change which option is cheaper.

Last updated: October 25, 2026.